SECTION 69 BNS   ✦   Understand the Law. Know Your Rights.   ✦   Legal Insights · Resources · Guidance   ✦  
Home / Blog / Article
69BNS · KNOWLEDGE JOURNAL

Can A Married Woman File A False Promise Of Marriage Case Under Section 69 BNS?

False Promise of Marriage Section 69 BNS Case

Can a married woman accuse another man of a false promise of marriage? Know what Section 69 BNS says, key court judgments and legal remedies available to men.

NEW DELHI: A consensual extramarital relationship can turn into a serious criminal prosecution when a woman accuses another man of sexual exploitation on the false promise of marriage.

Under Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, a man can face imprisonment of up to 10 years for establishing sexual relations with a woman through deceitful means or a promise of marriage made without any intention of fulfilling it.

While the provision aims to punish sexual deception, it also raises serious concerns about the potential misuse of criminal law following the breakdown of consensual relationships.

But what if the woman making such allegations is herself already married? What if her divorce proceedings are still pending? What if both individuals knowingly enter into an extramarital relationship?

Several recent Supreme Court and High Court judgments have addressed these issues, emphasising the distinction between a false promise of marriage and a mere breach of promise.

Although Section 69 BNS does not prohibit a married woman from filing a criminal complaint, her existing marriage, the nature of the relationship, and the intention behind the alleged promise can become crucial defence grounds.

WHAT IS SECTION 69 BNS?

Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, came into force on 1 July 2024. It introduces a separate criminal offence dealing with sexual intercourse obtained through deceitful means or a dishonest promise of marriage.

The provision specifically applies to sexual intercourse that does not amount to rape.

The expression deceitful means also includes inducement for, or false promises of, employment or promotion and marrying by suppressing identity.

Punishment Under Section 69 BNS

ParticularsLegal Provision
Maximum punishment10 years imprisonment
Minimum punishmentNo prescribed minimum
FineApplicable
Nature of offenceCognizable
BailNon-bailable
Trial courtCourt of Session
Anticipatory bailSection 482 BNSS
FIR quashingSection 528 BNSS

Unlike an ordinary relationship dispute, an allegation under Section 69 BNS can expose a man to arrest, police investigation, criminal prosecution and years of litigation.

However, the mere existence of a physical relationship followed by a refusal to marry does not automatically establish this offence.

Read Also:- Section 69 BNS: Legal Protection or Weapon Against Men?

CAN A MARRIED WOMAN FILE A FALSE PROMISE OF MARRIAGE CASE UNDER SECTION 69 BNS?

Yes. Section 69 BNS imposes no express restriction preventing a married woman from filing a criminal complaint against another man.

However, whether such a complaint can survive judicial scrutiny is a different question.

When a woman is already married and voluntarily enters into a physical relationship with another man, the court may examine whether the alleged promise of marriage was genuinely responsible for her decision to establish sexual relations.

Her existing marriage, knowledge of her legal marital status, the nature of the relationship, communications between the parties, and the circumstances surrounding their separation become relevant.

For instance, consider a situation where a married woman voluntarily maintains a physical relationship with another man for three years. During this period, she neither obtains a divorce nor becomes legally eligible to remarry.

After the relationship breaks down, she alleges that the man had promised to marry her.

In such circumstances, the court may examine whether the relationship was based on mutual affection and voluntary participation or whether it was actually induced by a dishonest promise.

A woman’s right to file a complaint does not automatically establish a man’s criminal liability.

CAN A MARRIED WOMAN LEGALLY MARRY ANOTHER MAN WITHOUT DIVORCING HER HUSBAND?

Indian matrimonial laws impose restrictions on contracting another marriage during the subsistence of an existing valid marriage.

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955

Under Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, neither party should have a living spouse at the time of marriage.

Section 11 deals with the invalidity of marriages solemnised in violation of certain statutory conditions, including this restriction.

Furthermore, Section 15 regulates when divorced individuals can lawfully remarry, taking into consideration the applicable appeal rights and proceedings.

Special Marriage Act, 1954

Section 4(a) of the Special Marriage Act similarly requires that neither party has a living spouse.

Section 30 further regulates remarriage following divorce.

Therefore, where these laws apply, merely being unhappy in a marriage, living separately from one’s husband or initiating divorce proceedings does not confer the legal right to remarry.

This becomes particularly relevant when a married woman alleges that another man’s promise of marriage induced her into establishing a physical relationship.

However, a specifically dishonest promise to marry after the lawful dissolution of her existing marriage must be examined separately on its own facts.

WHAT MUST THE PROSECUTION PROVE UNDER SECTION 69 BNS?

The fundamental question in a false promise of marriage case is not simply whether the accused eventually refused to marry the complainant.

The relevant question is whether he ever genuinely intended to marry her when he made the promise.

1. Existence Of A Promise Of Marriage

There must be a factual foundation establishing that the accused made a promise of marriage.

A romantic relationship, expressions of affection, discussions about a possible future together or ordinary conversations between partners may not, by themselves, establish a fraudulent promise.

The surrounding circumstances and actual communications become important.

2. Dishonest Intention From The Beginning

The prosecution must establish that the promise was made without any genuine intention of fulfilling it.

A man may initially intend to marry a woman but subsequently reconsider his decision because of incompatibility, family opposition, financial circumstances or personal differences.

Such a change of circumstances cannot automatically establish that his original intention was dishonest.

3. Direct Connection Between The Promise And Physical Relationship

The alleged dishonest promise must have induced the woman into establishing sexual relations.

If a physical relationship existed independently of the alleged marriage promise, this may substantially affect the prosecution’s case.

4. Sexual Intercourse Not Amounting To Rape

Section 69 specifically applies to sexual intercourse obtained through the conduct described in the provision, where such intercourse does not amount to rape.

Where independent allegations establish sexual intercourse without consent, coercion or other ingredients of rape, separate criminal provisions may apply.

Criminal law cannot presume dishonest intention merely from the eventual failure of a relationship.

FALSE PROMISE OF MARRIAGE VS BREACH OF PROMISE OF MARRIAGE

Indian courts have consistently distinguished between a dishonest promise and a genuine promise that later goes unfulfilled.

False Promise Of MarriageBreach Of Promise Of Marriage
Dishonest intention from inceptionGenuine intention initially
Deliberate sexual deceptionSubsequent change of decision
Promise made to fraudulently induce intimacyRelationship may develop voluntarily
Criminal liability may ariseNot automatically a criminal offence
May attract Section 69 BNSMere breakup is insufficient

SUPREME COURT AND HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS ON FALSE PROMISE OF MARRIAGE BY A MARRIED WOMAN

Several Indian courts have quashed criminal proceedings initiated by married women against men over allegations of sexual exploitation on the false promise of marriage.

1. Pramod Kumar Navratna v. State of Chhattisgarh

Citation: 2026 INSC 124 | Supreme Court | 5 February 2026

A married woman, an advocate by profession, accused another advocate of rape on the false promise of marriage while her divorce proceedings were still pending.

The Supreme Court considered her subsisting marriage, legal knowledge and the consensual nature of the relationship.

Expressing concern over the misuse of criminal law, the Court observed:

“The misuse of the criminal justice machinery in this regard is a matter of profound concern”

The Supreme Court quashed the rape FIR, charge sheet and consequential criminal proceedings.

2. Habibur Rahman v. State of Kerala

Citation: 2026:KER:67015 | Kerala High Court | 3 September 2026

A married woman and mother of two accused a man of establishing sexual relations with her on the false promise of marriage.

Justice Jobin Sebastian examined her subsisting marriage and found that the allegations did not disclose the essential ingredients of Section 69 BNS.

The High Court quashed the FIR and consequential proceedings under Section 528 BNSS after examining the merits rather than relying solely on the parties’ settlement.

3. Zahid Shanavas v. State of Kerala

Citation: 2026:KER:67526 | Kerala High Court | 7 September 2026

A woman entered into a physical relationship with a man while she was legally married. She subsequently obtained a divorce, got engaged to him and later filed a criminal complaint.

The High Court found that the subsequent divorce and engagement did not establish that the original marriage promise was fraudulent.

The Court observed:

“A subsequent failure to marry, by itself, cannot retrospectively render consensual sexual intercourse an offence.”

The FIR and consequential criminal proceedings were quashed.

4. Mahendra Jatav v. State of Madhya Pradesh

Citation: 2026:MPHC-JBP:72604 | Madhya Pradesh High Court | 15 September 2026

Two married individuals allegedly maintained a physical relationship for nearly three years. The woman subsequently accused the man of sexual exploitation on the false promise of marriage.

The High Court considered their knowledge of each other’s marital status and the absence of specific material demonstrating fraudulent intention from the beginning.

The Court quashed the FIR, charge sheet and consequential proceedings.

5. Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat

Citation: 2026 INSC 987 | Supreme Court | 7 September 2026

A woman accused a man of establishing physical relations on the promise of marriage after he subsequently refused to marry her due to his mother’s opposition.

The Supreme Court directly examined Section 69 BNS and distinguished a dishonest marriage promise from a genuine promise that subsequently remained unfulfilled.

Finding that the complaint did not disclose the requisite deceitful inducement, the Supreme Court quashed the Section 69 BNS FIR.

6. Naim Ahamed v. State (NCT of Delhi)

Citation: (2023) 15 SCC 385 | Supreme Court

A married woman and mother of three maintained a physical relationship with the accused for several years and subsequently accused him of rape on the false promise of marriage.

The Supreme Court distinguished fraudulent inducement from a consensual relationship and set aside the man’s rape conviction.

7. Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra

Citation: (2019) 9 SCC 608 | Supreme Court

The Supreme Court held that a false marriage promise must be made in bad faith, without a genuine intention to fulfil it.

The Court further observed:

“The false promise itself must be of immediate relevance, or bear a direct nexus to the woman’s decision to engage in the sexual act.”

8. Amol Bhagwan Nehul v. State of Maharashtra

Citation: 2025 INSC 782 | Supreme Court | 26 May 2025

The Supreme Court examined allegations of sexual exploitation involving a relationship that began while the complainant was married.

Considering the circumstances of the relationship and the lack of sufficient grounds to establish fraudulent inducement, the Supreme Court quashed the criminal proceedings.

Although some of these judgments were delivered under the IPC, their reasoning on dishonest intention, consensual relationships, and fraudulent inducement remains relevant to interpreting Section 69 BNS.

CAN A WOMAN FILE A FALSE PROMISE OF MARRIAGE CASE UNDER SECTION 69 BNS AFTER DIVORCE?

A married woman may claim that she divorced her husband because another man promised to marry her. If the man subsequently refuses to marry her, she may accuse him of sexual exploitation on the false promise of marriage under Section 69 BNS.

However, obtaining a divorce does not automatically establish that the man’s earlier promise was fraudulent.

While examining such allegations, the court may consider the following factors:

  • Whether the promise of marriage was specifically made for marriage after divorce.
  • Whether the man had dishonest intentions from the beginning.
  • Whether the alleged promise induced the woman into establishing physical relations.
  • Whether subsequent disputes or a change in circumstances prevented the marriage.

If the relationship was consensual and the promise was initially genuine, a subsequent refusal to marry does not automatically attract criminal liability under Section 69 BNS.

However, if sufficient evidence establishes deliberate sexual deception from the beginning, criminal liability may still arise.

A subsequent divorce cannot, by itself, retrospectively convert a consensual extramarital relationship into a criminal offence.

CAN SECTION 69 BNS APPLY IF BOTH THE MAN AND WOMAN ARE ALREADY MARRIED?

When both the man and woman are legally married to their respective spouses and knowingly enter into an extramarital relationship, allegations of a false promise of marriage under Section 69 BNS become legally complex.

If both individuals voluntarily continue a physical relationship despite being aware of each other’s existing marriages, the court may examine whether the alleged promise of marriage was actually responsible for establishing sexual relations.

While determining criminal liability, the court may consider the following factors:

  • Whether both parties were aware of each other’s marital status.
  • Whether either party had initiated divorce proceedings.
  • Whether the alleged promise of marriage was dishonest from the beginning.
  • The duration and consensual nature of the relationship.
  • The circumstances that led to the filing of the criminal complaint.

However, the existing marriages of both parties do not automatically provide immunity from criminal prosecution if sufficient evidence establishes deliberate sexual deception, coercion or sexual assault.

A failed consensual extramarital relationship cannot, by itself, become a ground for criminal prosecution under Section 69 BNS.

IS AN EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR A CRIMINAL OFFENCE IN INDIA?

No. Consensual adultery is no longer a general criminal offence in India.

In Joseph Shine v. Union of India, (2019) 3 SCC 39, the Supreme Court struck down Section 497 IPC on 27 September 2018, thereby decriminalising adultery.

However, adultery continues to be a ground for divorce under applicable matrimonial laws.

This means that an extramarital relationship may have matrimonial and civil consequences without necessarily constituting a criminal offence.

The decriminalisation of adultery does not protect anyone from prosecution for independently established sexual offences, coercion, criminal intimidation or deception.

At the same time, Section 69 BNS cannot be treated as an automatic substitute for the repealed offence of adultery. Its own statutory ingredients must be satisfied.

CAN A MAN AUTOMATICALLY ESCAPE SECTION 69 BNS BECAUSE THE WOMAN IS MARRIED?

No. The woman’s marital status is not a blanket defence against criminal prosecution.

Every case depends on its specific facts and circumstances.

For instance, if a man deliberately makes a dishonest promise to marry a woman after her divorce and obtains sexual relations through that deception, criminal liability may arise if the statutory requirements are satisfied.

Similarly, allegations involving sexual assault, coercion, threats, blackmail or administering intoxicating substances must be independently examined.

Even a previously consensual relationship does not establish consent for every subsequent sexual act.

The legal defence must therefore focus on evidence, absence of fraudulent intention and the specific ingredients of the alleged offence rather than relying exclusively on the complainant’s marital status.

HOW CAN A MAN DEFEND HIMSELF AGAINST A FALSE SECTION 69 BNS CASE?

A man facing false allegations should avoid emotional confrontations and immediately prepare an evidence-based legal defence.

Step 1: Obtain The FIR Copy

Obtain a copy of the FIR and examine the precise allegations, dates, locations and criminal provisions invoked against you.

Identify when the alleged promise was made and whether the complaint explains how that promise induced the physical relationship.

Step 2: Establish The Woman’s Marital Status

Where legally obtainable, preserve relevant documents, including:

  • Marriage certificates.
  • Divorce petitions.
  • Family Court orders.
  • Divorce decrees.
  • Pending matrimonial appeals.
  • Communications acknowledging her existing marriage.

These documents may establish her marital status during the relevant period and help determine whether she was legally eligible to remarry.

Step 3: Preserve Complete Digital Evidence

WhatsApp messages, emails, photographs, call records and other electronic communications may become critical evidence.

Preserve complete conversations rather than selected screenshots that omit important context.

Messages demonstrating mutual affection, voluntary participation, knowledge of marital status or subsequent threats may become relevant to the defence.

Electronic evidence must comply with the applicable admissibility requirements under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, including certification wherever required.

Step 4: Prepare A Detailed Relationship Chronology

Prepare a chronological record of when the parties met, when the relationship began, the woman’s marital status, when marriage was discussed, when disputes arose and when the criminal complaint was filed.

A carefully prepared chronology can help identify material inconsistencies and establish whether the alleged promise preceded or followed the physical relationship.

Step 5: Apply For Anticipatory Bail

If there is a reasonable apprehension of arrest, the accused may approach the Sessions Court or High Court under Section 482 BNSS for anticipatory bail.

Anticipatory bail may protect the accused from custodial detention, subject to the court’s discretion and applicable conditions.

The woman’s existing marriage, nature of the relationship, documentary evidence, cooperation with the investigation and requirement of custodial interrogation may become relevant considerations.

Step 6: Explore FIR Quashing Before The High Court

Where the allegations fail to disclose the essential ingredients of Section 69 BNS, the accused may approach the High Court under Section 528 BNSS.

Potential grounds for FIR quashing may include:

  • Absence of fraudulent intention from the beginning.
  • Absence of a direct connection between the alleged promise and sexual relationship.
  • Admitted facts demonstrating that the statutory ingredients are missing.
  • Material contradictions apparent from undisputed records.
  • Criminal proceedings amounting to an abuse of the process of law.

However, the High Court ordinarily does not conduct a full trial while deciding a quashing petition.

Where material facts are seriously disputed and require examination of evidence, the matter may proceed to trial.

Step 7: Avoid Actions That Can Damage Your Defence

Do not delete messages, fabricate evidence, threaten the complainant, access her private accounts unlawfully or circulate intimate photographs.

Publishing information that reveals a complainant’s protected identity in a Section 69 BNS case may also attract legal consequences under Section 72 BNS.

Fight the case through evidence and legal strategy, not emotional retaliation.

CAN A MAN FILE A COUNTER CASE AGAINST A WOMAN FOR FILING A FALSE SECTION 69 BNS CASE?

Yes. A man can initiate legal proceedings against a woman if evidence establishes that she knowingly made false criminal allegations with the intention of causing injury.

Section 248 BNS – False Criminal Accusation

Since Section 69 BNS carries a maximum punishment of 10 years, deliberately instituting false criminal proceedings under this provision may attract punishment of up to 10 years of imprisonment and a fine under Section 248 BNS.

Other Legal Remedies Available To Men

Depending on the facts and evidence, a man may pursue the following legal remedies:

  • Section 351 BNS: Criminal intimidation.
  • Section 308 BNS: Extortion.
  • Section 356 BNS: Criminal defamation.
  • Proceedings for giving or fabricating false evidence.
  • Civil suit for damages arising from malicious prosecution.

However, FIR quashing or acquittal does not automatically establish that a complaint was false. Deliberate falsity must be independently established through appropriate legal proceedings.

CONCLUSION

Section 69 BNS was enacted to punish sexual deception, not to criminalise failed relationships or compel men to marry under the threat of imprisonment.

Recent Supreme Court and High Court judgments have reinforced that a woman’s existing marriage, the consensual nature of the relationship and the absence of fraudulent intention can become significant grounds of defence in false promise of marriage cases.

A woman’s right to seek justice against genuine sexual exploitation must not come at the cost of a man’s right to liberty, dignity and a fair trial.

Even after securing bail or getting an FIR quashed, a man may continue to suffer the consequences of damaged reputation, financial losses, mental trauma and professional setbacks. While courts can terminate criminal proceedings, they cannot always restore the years lost fighting deliberately fabricated allegations.

The law must punish genuine offenders while holding those who deliberately misuse it strictly accountable.

A man cannot be forced into marriage through fear of imprisonment. A failed relationship is not a crime, and criminal law must never become a weapon of personal revenge.

FAQs

  • Can A Married Woman File A False Promise Of Marriage Case Under Section 69 BNS?
    Yes, but her existing marriage can become a significant ground of defence.
  • Can A Man Be Arrested Under Section 69 BNS For Refusing To Marry A Married Woman?
    Yes, if the statutory grounds for arrest exist. Mere refusal to marry is not a criminal offence.
  • Can A Married Woman’s Section 69 BNS FIR Be Quashed?
    Yes. The High Court can quash the FIR under Section 528 BNSS on valid legal grounds.
  • Can An Extramarital Affair Attract Section 69 BNS?
    Not automatically. The essential ingredients of sexual deception must be established.
  • Can A Woman Face 10 Years In Jail For Filing A False Section 69 BNS Case?
    Yes. Section 248 BNS may attract up to 10 years of imprisonment if deliberate false prosecution is proved.
General information: This article is for educational purposes and is not personalised legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for guidance on your circumstances. Reading this website does not establish an advocate-client relationship.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Continue exploring.

More explainers and reading guides in the 69BNS journal.

Back to Blog ↗