A man refuses to marry his girlfriend after a physical relationship. Can a broken promise lead to 10 years in jail, or must deception be proved? What does the Supreme Court say?
NEW DELHI: A man falls in love, enters into a consensual physical relationship and discusses marriage with his girlfriend. Months or years later, the relationship ends. He refuses to marry her. She approaches the police, alleging that he established physical relations on a false promise of marriage.
Suddenly, the man faces the possibility of a criminal FIR, arrest and imprisonment extending up to 10 years.
But does refusing to marry your girlfriend amount to rape in India?
No. Refusing to marry someone is not, by itself, rape or a criminal offence. However, a deliberately false promise used to obtain sexual intercourse can attract criminal liability.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly distinguished between a genuine relationship that fails and a relationship involving deception from the beginning.
With Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) now in force, understanding this difference has become particularly important for men.
DOES REFUSING TO MARRY YOUR GIRLFRIEND AMOUNT TO RAPE?
Indian law does not make marriage compulsory merely because two adults have been romantically or physically involved.
A breakup, refusal to marry, disagreement between families or change in marriage plans does not automatically establish rape.
The critical question is whether sexual intercourse was consensual or involved unlawful conduct, including deception sufficient to attract the applicable criminal provision.
Courts examine whether:
- The man genuinely intended to marry when he made the promise.
- The promise was deliberately false from the beginning.
- The alleged false promise induced the woman to agree to sexual intercourse.
- The circumstances independently disclose rape or another sexual offence.
A broken promise and a false promise are legally different.
For example, a man may sincerely plan marriage but later face family opposition, incompatibility or other genuine obstacles.
Such circumstances must be distinguished from a situation where he never intended to marry and used the assurance only to obtain sexual intercourse.
WHAT DOES SECTION 69 BNS SAY ABOUT FALSE PROMISES OF MARRIAGE?
Section 69 BNS, effective from 1 July 2024, creates a separate offence covering sexual intercourse obtained through specified deceitful means or a promise to marry a woman made without any intention of fulfilling it.
The provision applies where the sexual intercourse does not amount to rape.
Its explanation also includes deceitful means involving false promises of employment or promotion and marriage by suppressing identity.
The punishment may extend to 10 years’ imprisonment and a fine.
Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), the offence is cognizable, non-bailable and triable by a Court of Session.
Section 69 BNS vs Rape: What is the difference?
| Legal provision | What it covers |
| Section 63 BNS | Defines rape, including intercourse without legally valid consent and other specified circumstances. |
| Section 64 BNS | Provides punishment for rape. |
| Section 69 BNS | Punishes specified deceitful conduct resulting in sexual intercourse that does not amount to rape. |
| Section 28 BNS | Addresses circumstances in which consent is ineffective, including consent given under a misconception of fact, subject to statutory requirements. |
The distinction matters. An allegation involving a false promise of marriage cannot automatically be described as rape merely because a relationship ended.
Equally, a marriage promise cannot excuse intercourse that independently amounts to rape. Where the woman is below 18, consent also cannot be relied upon to avoid applicable statutory sexual-offence provisions.
SUPREME COURT 2026: MAN REFUSES MARRIAGE AFTER MOTHER’S OBJECTION, FIR QUASHED
Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat & Anr. — 2026 INSC 987
On 7 September 2026, the Supreme Court delivered an important judgment concerning Section 69 BNS.
A Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran examined an FIR registered against Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani at Sayajiganh Police Station, Vadodara, Gujarat.
The complainant alleged that the man entered into physical relations with her on a promise of marriage but subsequently refused because his mother opposed the relationship.
According to the complaint, they met through a digital platform, became friends and later developed a romantic relationship.
Their first alleged physical relationship occurred on 12 February 2024. They also stayed together in a hotel in April 2024.
The Gujarat High Court had refused to quash the FIR. The man challenged that decision before the Supreme Court.
What did the Supreme Court examine?
The Bench considered the earlier judgment in Deepak Gulati v. State of Haryana, (2013) 7 SCC 675, concerning promises made dishonestly from the beginning and genuine promises later rendered impossible.
It then examined the language of Section 69 BNS, particularly the requirement of an intention never to fulfil the marriage promise.
The Supreme Court found that the complainant’s own account indicated a consensual relationship. Importantly, it did not establish that she agreed to the first sexual encounter only because of an assurance of marriage.
The Court also considered the mother’s later opposition to marriage significant in the circumstances of that case.
The Supreme Court quashed the FIR, finding insufficient grounds to continue the prosecution.
WHEN CAN REFUSING MARRIAGE STILL LEAD TO A SECTION 69 BNS CASE?
In Jayant Vats v. State (NCT of Delhi), the Delhi High Court examined a relationship that lasted about eight years.
The woman alleged that the man repeatedly promised marriage and established physical relations with her, but later refused to marry because their kundalis did not match.
During the bail proceedings, the defence argued that the parties had maintained a long relationship and that the failure to marry did not establish a false promise.
The complainant’s counsel relied on WhatsApp conversations, submitting that the man had previously assured her their kundalis matched and that marriage faced no obstacle.
The Court examined the messages, including one dated 14 September 2023 containing the words kal hi shaadi kar rahe hain hum.
On 17 February 2026, Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma declined regular bail, observing that the material raised a prima facie question about whether the marriage assurances were genuine.
But that was not the final development.
On 2 September 2026, Justice Girish Kathpalia granted the man regular bail after considering subsequent developments, including the complainant’s affidavit stating that the dispute arose from misunderstandings regarding marriage and that she supported his release.
The prosecution opposed bail, maintaining that the case could not simply be withdrawn by the complainant.
The Court granted bail while leaving the disputed question of consent and alleged deception for trial.
In AAM v. State of Madhya Pradesh, MCRC No. 22093/2026, Justice Himanshu Joshi examined allegations against a male bank manager.
Both individuals worked in banking, and their families had discussed marriage. The man argued the relationship was consensual and that the marriage negotiations showed genuine intent.
The State and complainant opposed quashing, relying on allegations that sexual relations followed repeated marriage assurances.
On 28 September 2026, the High Court refused to quash the proceedings under Section 528 BNSS.
The Court explained that a subsequent refusal to marry, by itself, is insufficient to establish criminal liability. However, it held that the competing claims concerning the man’s intention required evidence at trial.
The man’s education-related arguments about the complainant’s awareness and financial independence were not treated as conclusive.
SUPREME COURT: CONSENSUAL RELATIONSHIPS CANNOT AUTOMATICALLY BECOME RAPE CASES
In Samadhan Sitaram Manmothe v. State of Maharashtra & Anr., 2025 INSC 1351, decided on 24 November 2025, the Supreme Court considered an IPC rape prosecution arising from a relationship that continued for years.
The Bench of Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan examined whether the complainant’s allegations disclosed the necessary ingredients of the offences.
The Court referred to earlier decisions, including Mahesh Damu Khare v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 11 SCC 398, and Deepak Gulati v. State of Haryana.
The Court emphasised the distinction between sexual intercourse induced by a deliberately false assurance and intimacy arising during a consensual relationship.
It found that the material did not establish the alleged rape offences and quashed the prosecution.
This case arose under the IPC, not Section 69 BNS. Its discussion of consent, initial intention and the connection between the alleged promise and physical relations remains relevant, but it must be applied with due regard to the separate wording of Section 69.
WHAT EVIDENCE MATTERS WHEN A GIRLFRIEND ALLEGES A FALSE PROMISE TO MARRY?
A court cannot determine dishonest intention merely because the marriage never happened.
It may consider evidence relating to the beginning, continuation and breakdown of the relationship.
Important material can include:
- WhatsApp messages and chats: Whether marriage was promised, whether conditions were disclosed and what both individuals understood.
- Marriage discussions: Communication with parents, proposed ceremonies and actual steps towards marriage.
- Relationship chronology: When physical intimacy began, when marriage was discussed and when disagreements arose.
- Reasons for refusal: Family opposition, changed circumstances or other explanations, examined against earlier conduct.
- Statements and documents: The FIR, statements before the Magistrate, relevant records and material collected during investigation.
No single item automatically proves innocence or deception.
A long relationship, family involvement or the complainant’s financial independence cannot replace a proper examination of the evidence.
Similarly, an allegation made after the man becomes engaged to someone else is not automatically false merely because of its timing.
The law requires evidence of criminal conduct, not assumptions based on the breakup.
WHAT SHOULD A MAN DO IF HIS GIRLFRIEND THREATENS A RAPE OR SECTION 69 BNS CASE?
If a girlfriend threatens to file a rape case or a false promise of marriage complaint after a breakup, the man should act carefully and understand his legal rights. A threat or allegation does not automatically establish guilt, but ignoring it can create serious legal problems.
1. Preserve all relationship evidence
Save WhatsApp chats, emails, call logs, photographs and marriage-related discussions that may establish the nature of the relationship. Messages showing mutual consent, genuine marriage intentions or the reasons for the breakup may become important evidence. Never delete, alter or fabricate records.
2. Understand the allegations
If an FIR is registered, obtain a copy and examine the allegations with a criminal lawyer. Determine whether the complaint alleges rape, a deliberately false marriage promise under Section 69 BNS, coercion or another offence. A failed relationship alone does not prove criminal wrongdoing, but the exact allegations and supporting evidence matter.
3. Apply for anticipatory bail if arrest is feared
Under Section 482 BNSS, a man who reasonably apprehends arrest for a non-bailable offence may seek anticipatory bail from the Sessions Court or High Court.
Although Section 69 BNS is cognizable and non-bailable, arrest is not automatically compulsory merely because an FIR has been registered. Police must comply with the applicable legal safeguards, including Section 35 BNSS.
4. Consider quashing a false FIR
If the FIR does not disclose the essential ingredients of the alleged offence, the man may approach the High Court under Section 528 BNSS.
Read Also:- How To File 498A Or Section 85 BNS Quashing Petition Under Section 528 BNSS?
For example, if the allegations themselves show a genuine relationship without an initially dishonest marriage promise, there may be grounds to seek quashing. However, quashing is not automatic, particularly where disputed facts require evidence at trial.
5. Never agree to marriage under pressure
A man cannot be legally compelled to marry his girlfriend simply to avoid a criminal complaint. He should not agree to marriage, make payments or sign settlement documents under threats without proper legal advice.
Any settlement must be voluntary and lawful. Marriage or settlement does not automatically cancel criminal proceedings.
Remember: A man’s refusal to marry does not establish criminal guilt. The strongest defence is based on preserved evidence, timely legal action and the absence of the essential ingredients of the alleged offence.
CAN A MAN BE FORCED TO MARRY HIS GIRLFRIEND TO AVOID A CRIMINAL CASE?
No law requires a man to marry his girlfriend merely because they were in a consensual relationship.
Marriage must be voluntary and legally valid.
At the same time, a later offer to marry does not automatically erase criminal liability if an offence has already occurred.
A promise genuinely made and later broken is different from a promise deliberately used to deceive someone into sexual intercourse.
The appropriate legal response is to examine the evidence and applicable statutory ingredients, not presume guilt based on refusal to marry.
CONCLUSION
A failed relationship cannot automatically become a rape or Section 69 BNS case simply because a man refuses to marry his girlfriend. The law distinguishes between a genuine promise that could not be fulfilled and deliberate deception used to obtain sexual intercourse.
The Supreme Court’s 2026 judgment in Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani reinforces that the man’s intention when making the promise is crucial. A breakup alone cannot establish criminal guilt.
Every man has the right to refuse marriage without automatically facing criminal liability. At the same time, genuine allegations of deception must be investigated fairly.
Criminal law must punish proven wrongdoing, not failed relationships. Justice must depend on evidence, not allegations alone.
FAQs
- Can refusing to marry your girlfriend land you in jail?
Not for refusal alone. Deliberate deception may attract Section 69 BNS. - Can a breakup turn into a rape case?
A complaint can be filed, but a breakup alone does not establish rape. - Can a false marriage promise lead to 10 years in jail?
Yes. Section 69 BNS allows up to 10 years’ imprisonment and a fine. - Can the High Court cancel a Section 69 BNS FIR?
Yes, if legal grounds for quashing are established. - Can police arrest a boyfriend without a warrant?
Yes, where legally justified and subject to BNSS arrest safeguards.
Contact Us
Send a general enquiry to the 69BNS team. Please avoid sharing confidential case details.